Click To View Our Hours

Agape Creamery

Our homemade small batch ice cream is made with love daily on premises using only the finest and highest quality local ingredients.

"AGAPE"

| A - GA - PE | /N./

  1. THE HIGHEST FORM OF LOVE.
    SELFLESS, SACRIFICIAL, AND UNCONDITIONAL LOVE;PERSISTS NO MATTER THE CIRCUMSTANCES. THE HIGHEST OF THE FOUR TYPES OF LOVE IN THE BIBLE.
  2. HAVING THE MOUTH OPEN BECAUSE OF WONDER, SURPRISE, SHOCK, OR DELICIOUS ICE CREAM.
Agape Creamery ice cream quarts

Our Core Flavors

Vanilla
Chocolate
Peanut Butter Ripple
Black Razz
Cookies N' Cream
Mint Chip
Local Coffee
Birthday Cake
Banana
Smores
Coconut Joy
Gravel Road
Salted Caramel
Butter Pecan

Additional Rotating Secret Stache Flavors

PISTACCHIO
WEEKEND AT BROWNIES
CEREAL MILK
GRINCH
OH SNAP
CINNAMON
PUMPKIN ROLL
OLD BAY SWEET CORN
LEMON
MAPLE WALNUT

What Our Customers Say

Sample Gift Cards image

Buy Gift Cards

Purchase an e-Gift card to instantly send to a friend/family member or maybe yourself. Our e-Gift cards are valid at Agape Creamery and Lighthouse Beach Golf and never expire.

We also offer physical gift cards in our parlor! Captains Quarters gift cards are available at the Arcade.

Buy Gift Card